Mayonnaise, Revisited Recipe (2024)

Last Modified: Jan 18, 2023 by Paleo Leaper · This post may contain affiliate links · Leave a Comment

We've already touched on mayonnaise, but we also realized that mayo isso versatile and delicious that it's worth revisiting and reiterating how simple it can be to prepare at home.

Add to that the fact that healthy store-bought mayonnaise is not something thatexistsat the moment; all of them are prepared with oils that are very high in polyunsaturated fat.

Making mayonnaise doesn't have toturn into an endurance test of your whisking abilities, thanks to the help of commonkitchen tools.

Making mayonnaise by hand with only your arm, a bowl, and a whisk can certainly impress a few and makes for less cleaning, but it can frankly be exhausting and very frustrating if the mayonnaise ends up breaking.

Using either a blender, food processor, or handheld immersion blender is the easiest way to whip up a perfect mayonnaise every time. We like to use an immersion blender with the whisk attachment, but any tool you have that'll let you blend all the ingredients while you slowly pour in the oil will do.

Note: This mayonnaise is prepared with raw egg yolks, so it is to be avoided if the higherrisk of contracting a food-borne illnessis not a risk you're ready to take.Definitely make sure to keepyour homemade mayonnaise refrigerated.

Choosing the oil right

Mayonnaise is made primarily of oil, so choosing the right oil is, of course, very important. We like to use either only light olive oil or a combination of light olive oil with another oil like macadamia oil, avocado oil, melted lard, or melted ghee.

Mayonnaise is probably the only occasion where we'll use light olive oil instead of a higher quality extra-virgin olive oil, which would taste too strong for a mayonnaise.

It's also important to use a greater amount of oil that stays liquid even when placed in the refrigerator to prevent your mayonnaise from becoming as hard as a rock.

So, for example, if using lard or ghee, a good proportion would be to use¼ of the lard or ghee to¾ of olive oil.

Fixing a broken mayonnaise

A mayonnaise becomes broken if the oil is incorporated too fast with the mixture of eggs and becomes liquid and lumpy.

Fortunately, though, fixing a broken mayonnaise is not as complicated asit may seem. Simply take out a new bowl, add in egg yolk and 1 teaspoon of fresh lemon juice, and then slowly whisk or blend in your broken mayonnaise.

Flavor ideas

Mayonnaise can be augmented with quite an array of flavors to become an aioli, tartar sauce, Caesar dressing, ranch dressing, or pretty much whatever you'd like.

Here are a few ingredientsyou can play around with to create an almost unlimited variation of mayonnaise flavors: black pepper, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers,horseradish, garlic, dill, chili pepper flakes, chives, basil, ...

MayonnaiseRecipe

Yields: 1 ¼ cups Prep: 15 min

Ingredients

• 2 egg yolks;
• 1 cup of your chosen oil (e.g 1 cup of light olive oil);
• 1 teaspoon Dijon or homemade mustard;
• 4 teaspoon fresh lemon juice;
• 1 pinch of salt;

Preparation

1. Place the egg yolks, 1 teaspoon of lemon juice, the mustard, and the pinch of salt in a bowl or in the bowl of your food processor or blender.
2. Start whisking/blending everything together, and then start slowly drizzling the oil in.
3. Continue pouring in the oil slowly but steadily. An emulsion will eventually start to form, and you'll be able to pour in the oil more quickly.
4. Using a blender, immersion blender, or food processor makes it very easy, but if you decide to whisk it by hand, you'll have to whisk quite vigorouslyfor the whole process to prevent the mayonnaise from separating.
5. Your mayonnaise should be quite thick when all the oil is incorporated, and you can then add the remaining lemon juice and blend it in with the mayonnaise.
6. Enjoy and refrigerate the leftovers!

Here's a simple chicken salad we prepared with this batch of mayonnaise. We simply used some leftover cooked chicken that we shredded by hand with some diced celery, diced onions, snipped chives, as well as some paprika, salt, and pepper:

📖 Recipe